Online Now 975

UK to have open quarterback race

When Neal Brown was involved with Kentucky football as a player he had a front row seat for Tim Couch's improbable run to becoming a Heisman trophy finalist. Now that he's returned as the Wildcats' offensive coordinator one of his most critical decisions will be who plays quarterback in his incarnation of the 'Air Raid' attack that made Couch a star.

Maxwell Smith

Maxwell Smith threw for 975 yards and eight TDs in 2012 before getting hurt

Who will that be? Brown said Maxwell Smith, Patrick Towles and Jalen Whitlow will all get an opportunity to win the 2013 starting quarterback job outright beginning when Kentucky takes the field for spring practice.

“The way we're going to handle it, it's going to be an open competition,” Brown said. “All three guys will split the reps a third in spring practice, carry that competition through the summer into fall camp and see who the best man is.”

The evolution of Kentucky's offense in the next few seasons will likely rely heavily on which of those three players ultimately wins the job, and remains healthy. Smith sprinted out of the starting gate in 2012 by throwing for 975 yards and eight touchdowns against just four interceptions in three games before shoulder and ankle injuries limited him to just two snaps over the final nine games. Whitlow and Towles were pressed into duty earlier than anticipated and both looked like true freshmen, with the two combining to complete 52.7 percent of their passes for 1,034 yards, four touchdowns and three interceptions.

The competition could be further complicated by that fact that all three will be sophomores next season if Smith is allowed to use 2012 as a redshirt season because of his injuries.

“It's a good problem,” Brown said. “It's really not a (problem). It's a good situation. We've got three guys that can play quarterback in the Southeastern Conference. How we're going to handle that is, it's going to be an open competition. All three guys (are) good people, very interesting guys, excited about a fresh start. And it's going to be a fresh start, not only for them, but for all the guys on our whole football team. I'm only controlling the offense, but it's a fresh start.”

Brown's system is certainly quarterback friendly. While it relies on the run a bit more than that attack Hal Mumme, Mike Leach and Tony Franklin ran at UK with Couch and Dusty Bonner at the controls, the passing attack was prolific at Texas Tech with Brown as offensive coordinator. In his three seasons in Lubbock the Red Raiders ranked at least seventh nationally in passing offense each season, culminating in a 2012 campaign that averaged 361.9 yards per game, good for second in the country. During that same span, Texas Tech quarterbacks threw 112 touchdown passes against just 35 interceptions.

Perhaps more important is Brown said the offense won't be nearly as complicated as the pro-style playbook UK had been running under Joker Phillips and Randy Sanders.

“It's really a simple system,” Brown said. “The first three days of spring practice we'll install the whole system. It's a system that the quarterbacks will be able to learn in a two to three week period while I'm gone recruiting. They can watch some videos and really have a good idea of what we want to do when I get back.”

Brown, who remains close with Couch, said his initial meetings with the three scholarships quarterbacks on UK's roster went well.

“I said, 'Hey, I'm not going to spend a whole lot of time watching what you've done before. There's going to be some fundamental things that are non-negotiable that we're going to do. You all are going to start on the same level playing field: best man wins,'” Brown said. “I don't have any ties to any of the three of them. I'm going to coach them like they're my own, like I recruited them and the whole deal, but the best man is going to play.”

Matt May
    • Matt May said...

      http://kentucky.247sports.com/Article/Neal-Brown-says-Kentucky-will-have-open-quarterback-race-107388

      Neal Brown said Maxwell Smith, Patrick Towles and Jalen Whitlow will all get an opportunity to win the 2013 starting quarterback job outright beginning in spring practice.

      As it should be.

      UKlaw82

    • So refreshing about the offense being less complicated! I cannot wait till football season.

      Big Sarge

    • Thanks for the article, Matt.

      rompcat

    • I believe Max Smith has a leg up in a traditional spread due to his ability to diagnose and his quick release. However, I'm also very interested to see what Jalen Whitlow could do in a pistol-heavy offense relying on the zone read to run the football.

      I believe that if Smith or Towles wins the job, we'll see more of a traditional spread passing offense. Whitlow gives you an opportunity to go pistol and do something similar to what the Redskins have done with RGIII.

      I'm already anticipating the spring game, so we can see what our offensive and defensive sets and personnel look like.

      JDHLaw11

    • Seems rather obvious for a new staff wouldn't you think? I'd think the same for C, and OG, and OT, and etc. I.e., why wouldn't you unless you have AA's manning positions?

      This post was edited by vhcat1970 on 12/18/2012 at 4:38 PM

      vhcat1970

    • If i had to put money on it i would put it on Maxwell. But both Towles and Whitlow offer somthing to the table. It will be interesting to see Towles in a system that his head dosnt swim in.

      quagmire

    • The open competition for the QB spot is the fair way to do things and is a pleasant problem that Brown has in that he has 3 QBs vying for the job and all 3 bring something to the table. Personally I think Smith will win the top spot but Towles and Whitlow both have skills that may prove them warranting the position. Whitlow can run the ball much better than the other 2 but is lacking in the accuracy of throwing the ball. I dont care which gets the job in the end as long as it is the 1 most suited to run the new system that is being brought to the team next year.

      sleepydog

    • Towles will win this competition if the overall objective is a spread offense.

      mr289

    • Why do you think that? Short timing throws are the most important spect of the spread. Snap the ball and throw it on time.

      quagmire

    • Didn't really have a way to work this into the story but Brown was asked what the most important traits are for a QB in his system. Here was his answer:

      "Off the field things are the number one thing," Brown said. "He has to been a man of character. He has to be a tremendous leader. He’s got to work tremendously hard. Those are the things. Second thing, he has to be a good decision-maker. These are football aspects now. He has to be a good decision-maker. He has to be accurate with the football. Those are the two top priorities. That’s what we’ll instill in these guys, the three guys that are here. From a recruiting standpoint from here on out, those are the top priorities to look for.”

      Matt May

    • Thanks Matt. Good job Neal Brown. Our OC sure knows what to say. And his offenses at TTU were brilliant. Looking forward to fall saturdays in a big way right now. Gonna be fun watching this football team come together. The 2013 team will be the start of a whole new day in UK football..finally..thank you!!!

      BigBlueDawg12

    • mr289 said...

      Towles will win this competition if the overall objective is a spread offense.

      ummmm no. Towels may not even see the field at UK. The spread works best with a mobile QB who can throw the ball on time and hit his receiver in stride.

      Towles may not be mobile enough to do this.

      dvillepro1

    • dvillepro1 said...

      ummmm no. Towels may not even see the field at UK. The spread works best with a mobile QB who can throw the ball on time and hit his receiver in stride.

      Towles may not be mobile enough to do this.

      I think you are totally off base, no where did Brown say his QB had to be mobile, and if that was the case I am sure he would have said it.

      UKlaw82

    • Towles isn't Whitlow as far as mobility goes, but he is for sure as mobile as Max if not more so. Obviously way too early to say, but if I was a bettin man it will come down to Max vs Pat, mobility be damned!

      msdcatfan

    • I think its very possible Smith could win the QB battle, but, then I think it's equally possible and maybe even moreso, that he gets hurt 3-4 games into the season.. I like the fact that he'll stay in the pocket till the last possible minute and I love his accurracy and quick release, just think he's not mobile enough to sustain the hits he'll likely take because of his style of quarterbacking.. If accurracy is one of the biggest factors, then Towles would likely be the 2nd choice.. He's not terribly mobile himself, but, moreso than Smith and is accurrate and brings some leadership intangibles to the table..I still look for Whitlow to be a safety or wr when all's said and done..

      bluecatntn

    • dvillepro1 said...

      ummmm no. Towels may not even see the field at UK. The spread works best with a mobile QB who can throw the ball on time and hit his receiver in stride.

      Towles may not be mobile enough to do this.

      My reasoning was 1) I think he will be a better decision maker 2) His accuracy is superb 3) He will have a better leadership quality, and this is the big one... wait for it...this is info I guarantee you did not have...oh the suspense is killing me...4) that's just my gut feeling! whew I'm glad I could finally let you all in on that insider info!! ROTFLOL!! roflmao

      mr289

    • Towles ran a 4.62 40 last summer at UK and his shuttle time was the best at the elite 11 Camp. I think this staff will put him in position to show how mobile he is.

      To say he is not mobile is an ignorant comment.

      This post was edited by Oldschoolcat on 12/19/2012 at 8:30 AM

      Oldschoolcat

    • I dont doubt that Towles is mobile enough to operate the new system but I do question if he is accurate enough. Some of his passes looked a lot like passes thrown by Newton and Boyd. I accually though that Whitlow was more accurate than Towles. Smith IMO is the QB to run the system if he can just avoid another serious injury. He is accurate, has a quick release and IMO reads the field better than the other two. IMO if you give Smith time to make the reads and the throws he will cut a defense to pieces.

      If the OL isnt able to give proper protection to the less mobile Smith one of the more mobile QBs might get the call.

      Cll80

    • JDHLaw11 said...

      I believe Max Smith has a leg up in a traditional spread due to his ability to diagnose and his quick release. However, I'm also very interested to see what Jalen Whitlow could do in a pistol-heavy offense relying on the zone read to run the football.

      I believe that if Smith or Towles wins the job, we'll see more of a traditional spread passing offense. Whitlow gives you an opportunity to go pistol and do something similar to what the Redskins have done with RGIII.

      I'm already anticipating the spring game, so we can see what our offensive and defensive sets and personnel look like.

      As a DC area Skins fan, unfortunately I don't think Whitlow can do anything like what RG3 does. It requires not only a much more accurate passer (one of RG3's most underrated abilities), as well as an incredibly smart player. While I thought Whitlow was a great athlete, and could thrive at QB in certain systems, I don't see him able to run the pistol-based read-option spread like the Skins.

      I hate it for Max, but I really think when its all said and done, Towles will be the guy. The only leg up Max really had was that he understood the Charlie-Weis-like playbook we seemed to have.

      BigBlueNation 7

    • There will also be a true freshman in the mix during spring practice. Don't underestimate his ability or leadership qualities. This young man is a winner and is very competitive.

      mountainair

    • Max Smith has the edge right now, imo. And it's a much bigger one than most realize because of one simple thing and it isn't experience. It's leadership! Look at how the team responded to him this year and after he went down. They looked at him as their leader and unless Towles or Whitlow make vast improvements and can get the guys in their corner this off-season I expect a healthy Smith to remain the starting QB.

      cobbycobb

    • mountainair said...

      There will also be a true freshman in the mix during spring practice. Don't underestimate his ability or leadership qualities. This young man is a winner and is very competitive.

      Here are some quotes on your incoming Freshman QB out of an article on the Times Free Press web site today.

      "I told Coach Brown that I wasn't coming to sit and watch," Phillips said. "I know I'll be at the bottom of the [quarterback] ladder and that I'll still be the freshman earning his way, but I think coming in early will allow me to get to know the older players.

      "I don't think I'll be at the bottom of the charts as long as I would be if I had waited to go till next summer. I know I have to keep my nose to the grindstone and work extra hard, but I'm not going to Kentucky to hold a clipboard."

      His coaches comment.

      "He's a high-character kid with a big-time arm," Price said. "He comes from a winning program, and he'll play wherever he goes because he is so competitive."

      He will push the three that are there to get better and that's what you want and need.

      mountainair

    • dvillepro1 said...

      ummmm no. Towels may not even see the field at UK. The spread works best with a mobile QB who can throw the ball on time and hit his receiver in stride.

      Towles may not be mobile enough to do this.

      LOL... Towles is more mobile than Smith. He's an outstanding athlete for somebody his size.

      They haven't had a mobile qb at Texas Tech since Leach got there.

      Read what brown said about what he looks for in a qb. Mobility wasn't mentioned once.

      blah

      hoptownukfan

    • In terms of who will start...

      To me it's pretty obvious that Maxwell is VERY well suited for this offense. He's got the accuracy, decision making ability and the quick release.

      The difference between this offense and what we did with joker is that there will be far fewer "down field" throws. We will see a lot of quick crossing routes, screens etc...

      Texas Tech didn't have elite o-linemen but their qb's were rarely hit or sacked because of the design of the offense.

      Further, Maxwell's issues are not freak muscle pulls. He had a impact shoulder injury and a ankle sprain that all of us would have suffered.

      I'd say we see a qb depth chart next fall of

      1. Smith
      2 Towles
      3 Whitlow

      hoptownukfan

Already have an account? Sign In

Add a comment
Want to be involved in the discussion? Start Free Trial