Online Now 384

The House of Blue

The home for all discussion on UK athletics

On this Board 227
Record: 3046 (4/11/2012)

Online now 437
Record: 6210 (3/13/2012)

Boards ▾

The House of Blue

The home for all discussion on UK athletics

The Paddock

The place to discuss general topics outside of Kentucky

UK Ticket Exchange

Buy, sell or swap tickets

Reply

Football Recruiting: What's left?

  • JayCatz44 said...

    You can try to spin it however you want, but UK is stuck in neutral, and even took a step back last season. Last years class was a slow step in the right direction, but this class is pretty weak. UK must improve recruiting if they want to do more than compete every once in a blue moon.

    All those waiting for UK to start pulling in 4-5 star guys from Ga, Fla, S. Car. etc, I hope you are not holding your breath. You can continue to say it all you want it is not going ot happen. Let me repeat, "It's not going to happen."

    We will "build" and "project" and "scheme" and "redshirt" etc, our way to the 8-9 win mark and that's just the way it is. But if you think were going to recruit with the UGA's and the UF's and the LSU's of the world you are living in a parallel universe. I wish I were wrong. I'm just not. I'm a realist.

    flknopp

  • Great work J Drum! I agree with most on here that this class doesn't jump off the page, but I think Rock will get all of these young men ready to go. We need a RB, 2 more LB, and then we can sit and wait for the best of the best that remain leading up to and on signing day. I still think we will pull a 4* or two in the latter stages of this recruiting class. More and more of those guys are taking a long, hard look at UK. GO BIG BLUE!!!

    focust1

  • DACats86 said...

    I actually like this class much better than the last one. Of course, I'm one of those guys that would be happy if we only recruited DL and OL...

    I'm in that same rowboat with you.

    signature image

    E-mail: JDRUM@247SPORTS.COM Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/#!/JDrumUK

    Jeff Drummond

  • I think the last two classes have been very good and this one isn't finished. Of course you don't really know until they get on the field for a couple of years but I like the look of these guys.

    zcats

  • JayCatz44 said...

    You can try to spin it however you want, but UK is stuck in neutral, and even took a step back last season. Last years class was a slow step in the right direction, but this class is pretty weak. UK must improve recruiting if they want to do more than compete every once in a blue moon.

    That is so very, very wrong.

    signature image

    Twitter - @JEdwar247

    Josh Edwards

  • DACats86 said...

    I actually like this class much better than the last one. Of course, I'm one of those guys that would be happy if we only recruited DL and OL...

    i have to agree. most of the guys that are not ranked high in the star arena, the coaches have seen in person.

    and by in person i mean had them in camp, got to talk to them, teach them, watch them up close one on one.

    that is very important. what's better, watching game film or you tube highlight tapes or standing over the player in Lexington and watching that player work for you.

    i would take the latter everyday of the week.

    goldenbearcatz

  • Jeff Drummond said...

    What do you base that on? They're actually pretty similar, and follow the staff's blueprint for how they have to operate. If you like one, you should like the other.

    The players qualities. Too many project types in this class, who for the most part lack quality offers. I can see 3 to 4 being really good, while others will provide depth at best. Last years class was a step in the "right" direction. However, you want to improve class by class. You don't want to finish 11th or 12th in the SEC in recruiting. You know where that gets you? Finishing 11th or 12th in SEC play.

    signature image

    JayCatz44

  • WildcatDawg22 said...

    That is so very, very wrong.

    Glad you offered nothing to the discussion. So we didn't take a step back last season finishing 6-7?

    signature image

    JayCatz44

  • Jeff Drummond said...

    I'm in that same rowboat with you.

    As am I.

    signature image signature image signature image

    "Nothing great was ever achieved without enthusiasm." ~ Emerson

    alphacat93

  • Jeff Drummond said...

    I'm in that same rowboat with you.

    I love this class!

    You can NEVER have enough OL & DL.

    Toth - One of the top 3 OL from Indiana. Big kid with the frame to add good weight.

    Graffree - Very underrated DL that IMHO will be one of the top incoming freshman from this class.

    Myers - Another big frame that has already added weight. I would put money on the fact schools are still recruiting Zach.

    Watson - Big, Strong kid that gives another OL commit that had other SEC offers.

    Newton, Chapman, Ross, Pearson(if he ever makes it),Jones and Swindle are all big strong kids that will gives us quality depth on both sides of the ball.

    Not sure why people are so upset with this class?

    Whitaker568

  • JayCatz44 said...

    Glad you offered nothing to the discussion. So we didn't take a step back last season finishing 6-7?

    What about you? You offer your doom and gloom posts but how would you do things differently? What exactly are you offering to the discussion? What is Joker doing wrong? Apparently, the answer is not cheating, lol.

    I get what your saying, but like someone already tried to tell you, we are slowly closing that gap and that's where we are right now. You need to accept that and then you will see the progress we are making. Are you honestly expecting us to just start randomly recruiting 4 and 5 star players?

    MossCat15

  • Whitaker568 said...

    I love this class!

    You can NEVER have enough OL & DL.

    Not sure why people are so upset with this class?

    Big uglies aren't sexy.

    My favorite recruit so far - Jordan Watson. Still can't believe we got that kid!

    DACats86

  • So unless a kid has offers listed on a recruiting site the summer prior to his Sr year he is a "project" at best. That I assume is based on this staff never having shown the ability to project talent. Wow just wow.

    bigcat65

  • MossCat15 said...

    What about you? You offer your doom and gloom posts but how would you do things differently? What exactly are you offering to the discussion? What is Joker doing wrong? Apparently, the answer is not cheating, lol.

    I get what your saying, but like someone already tried to tell you, we are slowly closing that gap and that's where we are right now. You need to accept that and then you will see the progress we are making. Are you honestly expecting us to just start randomly recruiting 4 and 5 star players?

    I'm not offering doom and gloom. I never said we wouldn't have a good season or UK is poised to be a nothing program. I'm stating how I see things. I've just stated my opinion. You don't have to agree with me, and that's fine. Most who question coaches around here are seen not as fans and are run off for having a different opinion.

    The discussion was about recruiting and the class we currently have. I commented about how I feel about this class, thus contributing to the discussion.

    First and foremost, UK football will never be more than what they are if fans are okay with finishing towards the bottom of the SEC. That's where we finish typically every season. Are we competing? Sure, if you consider going 8-17 the last three seasons in the SEC competing, then okay. I always played the game of football to win, not compete. The coaches I had taught to never accept moral victories. I'm sure Joker is the same way.

    What can we do to improve recruiting? First, the administration needs to put more money into the program. Fans need to demand that they do so too. Joker should have fired Brown, not keep him on staff taking in $250,000+ and showing little to nothing on the recruiting trail for it. Use it to bring in one or two recruiters like Tee Martin. Being creative can also go a long way in exciting and getting a recruits attention. UK football and its events are very poorly promoted. Maybe Joker could talk to Cal about creating, marketing, selling a brand. Joker just doesn't excite me when he talks. Shoot, UK practices are about as tight-lipped as anything.

    Are we closing the gap or are we just stuck in the mud spinning? We basically finish with the same record every season. At the rate we're going, it's going to take 20 to 30 years to be even an middle of the pack SEC team, if that.

    signature image

    JayCatz44

  • I don't get all the doom and gloom .I think what we need is the perfect storm .We need this years team to beat at least of Tennessee or Florida .We need to be exciting on offense and unpredictable on defense .We need one or two players to have better than average seasons ... such as Newton ,Ukwu or Clemons .
    We need Randall Cobb to be Randall Cobb .If he or any other ex UK players can make some noise then it helps the UK brand .Their name recognition becomes our recruiting tool .Then maybe we change the minds of our own fans and some of the four and five star recruits .

    mattrudd

  • bigcat65 said...

    So unless a kid has offers listed on a recruiting site the summer prior to his Sr year he is a "project" at best. That I assume is based on this staff never having shown the ability to project talent. Wow just wow.

    You're entitled to your opinion. Once you realize our coaches are humans and not Gods then you'll know they do make mistakes. Can they project talent? Sure, but so can a handful of other coaches in the SEC and around the country. They're certainly not the best, and to act like they are the only ones is really naive. Also, they're all Seniors now, in school, and most have started their season.

    This post was edited by JayCatz44 on 8/31/2011 at 4:19 PM

    signature image

    JayCatz44

  • Spin what? Do you deny that we've recruited better? Do you deny that we've had winning seasons (for the most part) over the last 5 yrs? (And you can't reference our weak OOC schedule.....go back and look, we've been playing a weak OOC schedule for the last 10-15 yrs) Do you deny that we beating teams in the past 5 yrs that we haven't in a while? Do you deny that we are not losing as badly to teams as we have? Do you deny that we are putting more players in the NFL on average than we have? Do you deny the fact that 247, Rivals, Scout, and ESPN have touted the fact that our recruiting is getting better? What if we put together a decade of 7 win seasons and a couple of 8 win seasons....what will your excuse be then?

    I would argue that your "spin" is to downplay everything someone posts. Perhaps for attention (like I'm giving you now), perhaps to satisfy your ego, perhaps to placate your pessimism. Whatever the cause it's annoying and time to move on.

    BlueRaider22

  • JayCatz44 said...

    You're entitled to your opinion. Once you realize our coaches are humans and not Gods then you'll know they do make mistakes. Can they project talent? Sure, but so can a handful of other coaches in the SEC and around the country. They're certainly not the best, and to act like they are the only ones is really naive. Also, they're all Seniors now, in school, and most have started their season.

    lol, no one said our coaches are gods. You are going from your opinion (extreme), and claiming we are on the other end of it but in actuality, we are in the middle (realistic). You can demand that become SEC champs in one year all you want, but that's just not the way things are done without cheating. Not in this conference. If you are a Debbie downer you will always find negativity, but it is a fact we are getting better players, and accumulating more depth than we have had since I have been watching UK Football. We have been competing with teams that were blowing us out regularly just 5 or 6 years ago. We have been doing so with "inferior" players and really no quality depth, so you tell me, does our coaching staff not deserve credit for that? You act like we are still on Vandy's level or something, but in reality we are trading games with Teams like Miss. State and Georgia, does this not show improvement. Did we not take Auburn to the final seconds and beat a top 10 USC team last year?

    Also, again You point to the one sore spot on our coaching staff and refuse to give Joker any credit for the coaching changes he has made. All he is doing is being fair to Brown (who is an excellent DB coach in his own right, so it's like he's some liability), and I expect that he (Brown) will not be around much longer.

    Look, we are not Alabama and never will be. There will always be negative for you to point to if that's what your looking for. You certainly are entitled to your opinion, even if it does fly in the face of what is actually going on.

    MossCat15

  • JayCatz44 said...

    You're entitled to your opinion. Once you realize our coaches are humans and not Gods then you'll know they do make mistakes. Can they project talent? Sure, but so can a handful of other coaches in the SEC and around the country. They're certainly not the best, and to act like they are the only ones is really naive. Also, they're all Seniors now, in school, and most have started their season.

    You just have a very naive of how the recruiting game is played in the SEC. People talk about how great Steve Spurier is but what was his SEC record his first 3 seasons? 11-13 with back to back 3-5 records. This while recruiting the very fertile grounds of SC and with a lot of support from untraceable donations from boosters that "assist" the program. KY isn't going to sign 4-5 star talent. They are not going to cheat, we have already gone down that path multiple times, so their only option is to project talent. Your refusal to understand how recruiting really works is truly amazing. Outdone only by your stubborn refusal to even remotely complement our coaching staff and their abilities.

    UK coaches are not Gods, they make plenty of mistakes but they don't cheat and I respect they understand Ky doesn't have a recruiting base and a number of obstacles you apparently don't think exist. I can appreciate the resistance to try and bend the rules and take short cuts with the prodding of so called fans like yourself. I think this is a great staff and guys like Nord, Summers, Martin, Turner, Pardue, Minter and Rock Oliver are only here because of Joker. Without Joker you don't have any of them.

    As for Steve Brown, punching bags and scapegoats go with being fans but enough already. Why wouldn't Joker want to keep an accomplished DB coach. Why wouldn't he want to keep a coach that played DB in the NFL and coached DBs on a super bowl winning team. You don't know what impact Steve Brown has made in recruiting other then what you read on a few fan sites which means you know absolutely NOTHING. The coaches respect Brown the players respect Brown and just because an uneducated group of fans that only understanding of football comes from playing video games is meaningless.

    Whats amazing to me is that a group of fans like yourself spend more time following recruiting and are completely clueless about on field performance. I imagine you are one of the "fans" calling for Chuck Smith head. He didn't get Dawson so fire him. But how many years in a row has Smith put and All SEC LB on the field? Lets count them.
    Woodyard
    Kelley
    Johnson
    Maxwell
    Trevathan

    Yea, that just screams incompetence.

    bigcat65

  • BTW most schools offer kids they get in camp. UK's strategy and plan is to identify kids they like and offer. Not based on recruiting profiles not based on what other teams do. But based on years of experience evaluating, developing and projecting talent. UK is getting better at it because their camps are growing as they have more and more success on the field.

    You want to dismiss the class after a couple of games into their SR year then fine. That is your right but no coach that gets paid to evaluate talent or to coach in the SEC does it. So, your "opinion" isn't shared by anyone with any football knowledge whatsoever.

    bigcat65

  • Jeff Drummond said...

    I'm in that same rowboat with you.

    Big Uglies win Football games, plain and simple. I think 8 to 9 OL and DL in every class is ideal. The rowbaot is filling up. I'm in. I CANNOT WAIT TILL TOMORROW NIGHT!

    cully26

  • JayCatz44 said...

    I'm not offering doom and gloom. I never said we wouldn't have a good season or UK is poised to be a nothing program. I'm stating how I see things. I've just stated my opinion. You don't have to agree with me, and that's fine. Most who question coaches around here are seen not as fans and are run off for having a different opinion.

    The discussion was about recruiting and the class we currently have. I commented about how I feel about this class, thus contributing to the discussion.

    First and foremost, UK football will never be more than what they are if fans are okay with finishing towards the bottom of the SEC. That's where we finish typically every season. Are we competing? Sure, if you consider going 8-17 the last three seasons in the SEC competing, then okay. I always played the game of football to win, not compete. The coaches I had taught to never accept moral victories. I'm sure Joker is the same way.

    What can we do to improve recruiting? First, the administration needs to put more money into the program. Fans need to demand that they do so too. Joker should have fired Brown, not keep him on staff taking in $250,000+ and showing little to nothing on the recruiting trail for it. Use it to bring in one or two recruiters like Tee Martin. Being creative can also go a long way in exciting and getting a recruits attention. UK football and its events are very poorly promoted. Maybe Joker could talk to Cal about creating, marketing, selling a brand. Joker just doesn't excite me when he talks. Shoot, UK practices are about as tight-lipped as anything.

    Are we closing the gap or are we just stuck in the mud spinning? We basically finish with the same record every season. At the rate we're going, it's going to take 20 to 30 years to be even an middle of the pack SEC team, if that.

    Completely different looking class of athletes just came in with this 2011 class. With the staff they have now and the strength & conditioning program under Rock, I think you're going to see steady improvement.

    People who have followed my postings a long time know I don't sugarcoat recruiting classes. I try to tell it like it is. I REALLY like what they're doing right now.

    signature image

    E-mail: JDRUM@247SPORTS.COM Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/#!/JDrumUK

    Jeff Drummond

  • My twocents here TIFWIW:

    Hard to judge a class right off the bat. Have to give it some time. The two players I was most excited about in the 2010 class--Jerrell Priester and Alex Smith--aren't even with the program anymore.

    With that being said, I think this group is the best looking group I've seen come through UK since I've been covering the team.

    But when you talk about UK making improvements in recruiting, this isn't something that's just going to happen over night. You can't just expect UK to start beating out Florida, Alabama, etc. for recruits on a consistent basis yet. Just not going to happen. It'd be like South Carolina or Auburn beating out UK for basketball recruits. Just not realistic.

    In my opinion, UK has to continue to pick its spots with the higher rated recruits and make its money evaluating talent and making the most of "mis-fit toys" like Trevathan, Ukwu, et al.

    Just my twocents

    signature image

    Chris Fisher

  • Chris Fisher said...

    My twocents here TIFWIW:

    Hard to judge a class right off the bat. Have to give it some time. The two players I was most excited about in the 2010 class--Jerrell Priester and Alex Smith--aren't even with the program anymore.

    With that being said, I think this group is the best looking group I've seen come through UK since I've been covering the team.

    But when you talk about UK making improvements in recruiting, this isn't something that's just going to happen over night. You can't just expect UK to start beating out Florida, Alabama, etc. for recruits on a consistent basis yet. Just not going to happen. It'd be like South Carolina or Auburn beating out UK for basketball recruits. Just not realistic.

    In my opinion, UK has to continue to pick its spots with the higher rated recruits and make its money evaluating talent and making the most of "mis-fit toys" like Trevathan, Ukwu, et al.

    Just my twocents

    QFT!!

    signature image signature image signature image

    "Nothing great was ever achieved without enthusiasm." ~ Emerson

    alphacat93

  • It's sad that no matter how much UK improves year in and year out, the football team is still the ugly step-sister on campus! J Drum & other guys who make it their job to evaluate recruiting classes, and give critism where it's needed, say that this incoming class is the most exciting class they've seen! Does that in its own right not make you want to stop and think, "Hmm. Maybe the table is turning and we're finally making some significant progress?" I believe beyond the shadow of a doubt that there are several future NFL players in the '11 recruiting class.

    I don't know about the rest of the fans on this site, but I am sick and tired of reading all of the critism thrown at Joker. All I hear around the office is, "Joker's not the answer. Fire Joker and give the team to someone else. We need a REAL coach to come in and right the ship." Wake up people, we have had a wonderful coaching staff for some time now! These high school kids relate to the staff in place now and absolutely love Coach Phillips. The past seven years has seen the most consistent improvement in UK football ever! Go back and check the record books. We were a couple of plays away from winning the SEC East last year! Also, take a look at how many players Coach Brooks and Coach Phillips are getting to the NFL as compared to previous decades. I'm sure there is absolutely no comparison.

    So, the next time you find yourself feeling as though UK football is not progressing, do a little research and look at how far things have really come. If landing 4 & 5 star guys is the only thing you worry about, take a look at all the college programs, that have been traditional power houses, that are being investigated and punished for decades of cheating. I'm so thankful that we are not one of those programs! I'd rather keep pushing along with these baby steps of evaluating talent and fielding an exciting and competitive team that is getting better year in and year out, than to see us take another huge step back like we did with Mumme and the Air Raid Era.

    Keep up the good work J Drum and crew & GO BIG BLUE (Beat those Toppers)!!!cheers

    focust1